Recent environmental soil testing of Ritzer Field shows that there is arsenic in the soil, but at levels not high enough to pose a safety risk to those using it, according to the South Orange-Maplewood School District.
Superintendent of Schools Jason Bing announced at the Board of Education meeting on Thursday night that the soil surface arsenic levels on Ritzer Field – the field behind Columbia High School – averaged 22.6 mg per kg of soil and that environmental health specialists say that arsenic levels up to 34 “present no elevated health risk to students participating in sports or recreational activities on Ritzer.”
[See the Arsenic Toxicological Evaluation Report and a letter to district families attached below.]
“We want to share what these numbers mean, directly from the environmental and health experts evaluating the site. The field is safe for athletic and physical education usage at this time. Again: Ritzer is safe for athletic and physical education usage at this time,” he emphasized.
Bing said he wanted to read the letter he is sending out to families in public before sending it out “so everybody has a better understanding of the purpose of the letter and not to alarm our community or athletes or our physical education or community members that utilize the field.”
Bing said the district will be consulting with the NJ Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) to determine what the best course of action regarding the arsenic in Ritzer.
The Board also discussed why it is taking so long to bring the Ritzer options to the Board of School Estimate for a vote. Board 2nd Vice President Malini Nayar, chair of the Facilities, Finance and Transportation (FFT) committee, said that at its last meeting, the committee reviewed the Ritzer field options, costs, tax impact and playability analysis and said the District still needs to update the costs and revise the presentation.
Nayar said the committee concluded it’s time for a broader full-board discussion on next steps. “At this point, I think there’s a bit of fatigue across even FFT and the district itself,” regarding Ritzer, she said.
Bing told the board that the district is looking at all the facilities projects that need to be done, including improving bathrooms, corridors and auditoriums in addition to Ritzer Field, and is creating a few tier levels for various project requests, showing how much can be done within each funding tier, i.e. $50 million, $75 million, $100 million, etc.
And Nayar encouraged the board to review the FFT committee minutes, which has a summary of the capital projects that “were prioritized by the architect group, totaling $258 million, and we discussed that that is not a number that we can actually prioritize at this point, so that has to be whittled down to something that we can actually afford debt service on.”
RELATED: South Orange-Maplewood Board of Ed Discusses Potential Ritzer Field Compromise
Board member Bimal Kapadia said he does not think there is any resistance from the community or even the Board of School Estimate when it comes to capital infrastructure projects such as building improvements, auditoriums, basic maintenance and safety – only resistance to the turfing of Ritzer Field.
“So when we talk about fatigue, it’s because of the sandbagging. It’s because of the rhetoric. It is because of the over analysis of all these things that were going back and forth,” he said. “The analysis has been the same. The numbers are just higher because it’s two years later.”
Kapadia urged the board and the district to “have conviction” and put Ritzer together with the capital projects and support Bing on whatever decision – “turf, grass whatever it is” and move forward with it, noting that a turf field like Underhill is heavily used like any other field on the weekends by the towns.
“That field is overrun by sports, particularly flag football, that is being used by the township,” he said. “And they’re the ones that are also giving us the resistance on trying to revitalize our field. It’s a little bit of hypocrisy. And I think we have to have the conviction to say it…I don’t even know how many years this discussion’s been there, so let’s just put it behind us, so we can move forward.”
This story was first published on November 1, 2026, and updated with pdfs of the Arsenic Toxicological Evaluation Report and letter to district families on November 4, 2026.

