WATCH: Residents ‘Love’ New Businesses on Boyden/Newark Way, But Want Help With Traffic & Parking

by Mary Barr Mann

The Maplewood Township Code Committee will get to work on an updated plan for the area — after some tense discussion.

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

Across about 90 minutes of presentation and conversation on October 22 at the Maplewood Community Center on Burnett Avenue, numerous residents of the Hilton and Lightning Brook neighborhoods voiced their support for the burgeoning restaurant/arts/business district on Newark Way and Boyden Avenue — but expressed frustrations about traffic and parking enforcement by the township.

After township officials introduced themselves and explained some of what they do — including Planning Board Chair Karen Pisciotta, Township Administrator Patrick Wherry, Police Chief Niheema Malloy, Director of Community Development Annette DePalma, and Township Engineer and Director of Public Works Paul Kittner — residents took to the microphone.

(Public comments begin at 31:41 in the video below.)

But first, moderator and District Leader Bill Gifford asked about discussions that the Dept. of Public Works facility on Boyden Avenue could be utilized to provide community or business district parking.

Wherry explained, “The idea of parking at DPW is one we’ve been thinking about, … and depending on how it’s used and when it’s used, obviously it’s very active for public works and we have very large trucks going in and out of there constantly, even on the weekends.” Wherry said that the township was willing to reevaluate if there is capacity at DPW, but noted that there are actually four vacant lots in the area that the township could consider to see “if those could be made available for parking.”

One is a vacant parcel that the township has “some use of” and the others are three parcels owned by Provident Bank, which the township is currently engaged with to discuss affordable housing development.

“We hope that some combination of those lots will give us the opportunity to put up 100% affordable housing in that area,” said Wherry. “We don’t right now know exactly what that’s going to look like and how we can assemble those lots.” Wherry added, “It’s too early to say what would be available for parking and what we want to make available for housing. Until we decide that, that’s something we’re very actively engaged on right now.”

Public Comments

Priscilla Miller said that she and her husband Bernie have lived on Jacoby Street for 33 years and appreciate the new businesses, but want to see more trash cans and traffic enforcement.

“I just had to say, first of all, it’s so good to see good businesses, businesses that you won’t mind your children going into, to be able to take a part in. It may be as a job, it may be as an intern, it may be as a customer. Let me get a slice, a piece of cheese. But all these things are just beautiful in my opinion.”

Miller then asked for improvements.

“It just looks like the policy of the broken windows when you come back to your home and you see the little bottles and cans in front of your curb, that’s a concern. Maybe a garbage can or something or another could be instituted in front of the businesses … or spaced out within the blocks. ”

“The other is we have heard a lot of cars ripping down the street,” said Miller, who added that she supported installing speed bumps.

She also said she supported more shared housing — whether for elderly parents or taking in younger roommates or boarders. “That is so needed for our young people.”

A Newark Way resident named Donna asked for more lighting at the Newark Way DeHart Park entrance — and throughout the park.

“There used to be a nice, very tall pole with light at night that hasn’t been lit for many years,” said Donna. “Also, I noticed at times that lighting in the park itself is totally out. I don’t know if we can get some sort of lighting that may be not as bright, because I also don’t want to see it in my bedroom, but where you feel a little more, you know, safe. Not that the neighborhood is unsafe, but I think it’s in your psyche. It’s dark. I don’t want to walk through the park.”

She also complained about the smell of gas in the neighborhood.

“I don’t know what can be done about it. I’ve called [PSEG] throughout the years. They’ll come down in my basement, check, and they always say it’s okay in the range. But range could be from one to five, but if it’s 4.8-5, it’s within range, doesn’t mean it’s safe.”

She expressed concerns that more housing in the area “would just add to more volume of traffic.”

“That’s a consideration also,” responded Wherry.

Former Deputy Mayor Jamaine Cripe, a 23-year Jacoby Street resident, said she had been pushing for speed humps for decades.

“I’m very glad to see the mock-up we made, Mr. Kittner, in regards to speed humps because Jacoby Street personally, in the 23 years I’ve lived there, we’ve tried to get speed humps three different times and we never got the signatures,” said Cripe. “So the fact that you’re actually just going to say it, put it in, makes me happy.”

Cripe asked for more thoughtful parking enforcement, but also pivoted to transit.

“I was wondering, because of the businesses and the fact that I actually do love the kind of Brooklyn feel of the corner where people do a lot of walking, and … I know with Pallet [Brewing]’s application years ago, that was their whole model. They want people to take Lyfts and have a designated driver and not have a ton of cars. Would the township be interested in or considering using the jitneys maybe on the weekends so people can park elsewhere or stay home and just get picked up maybe at the jitney stops and get dropped off?”

Cripe asked for more police presence — but in a passive policing mode.

“When we first started coming and visiting the corner shop when it was that really scary liquor store on the corner, we used to always see a police officer just park in the parking lot and you could visibly watch the behavior change of the people in the community driving,” said Cripe. “Some of the noise, some of the aggression just fell away because a police car was parked there. No lights flashing, just presence. I don’t want anybody to have to pay additional tickets or be involved, God forbid, in an accident, but could we have a bigger police presence in more of a subtle way like that? Even if it’s the police officer standing on the corner having a conversation, that would be helpful.”

Hughes Street resident and local business owner [Home Sweet Home Tattoo] and artist [The Art Generators] Maggie McGowan agreed that improvements needed to be made to lighting and traffic enforcement.

“I do agree with the lighting situation because a lot of the times we are leaving late at night, and I very, very much support the speed bump thing because that existed way before the restaurant developments happened, of people just cutting through these blocks. So I just don’t necessarily want to tie that into because of the development. It existed before that.”

Former Township Committee member David Huemer asked for greater enforcement against trucks parked on Boyden — either by delivery services or DPW. Cripe inserted that this was also an issue at Rutgers and Newark Way with the plumbing supply company located there.

Huemer asked that the township not add housing density to the area.

“And plant some trees,” said Huemer.

“We have an active waiting list for trees, and every year we have a tree program to plant,” said Kittner. “So if you want a tree, grab one of my cards and email me, and, and we’ll add you to the list.”

Wherry added, “The township Committee has in recent years put more and more money into the tree planting budget, and what had been a longer multi-year wait list last year either we got through all of it or just about all of it, where you wouldn’t wait more than a year to get a tree planted. So anybody who wants a tree in front of their house, we encourage you to submit an application for that.”

Mary Boehner of Jacoby Street said that speeding was a huge problem on Boyden and asked for stop signs.

She also noted the danger of people who were using Jacoby Street private driveways to turn their cars around.

“We have this great little group of girls. They’re about 10 girls that are between the age of five and about 12,” said Boehner. “I call them the girl posse, and they just are running up and down the block all weekend long. It’s just so sweet to see, but I feel like something’s going to happen. Cars are constantly turning around in our driveways.”

Boehner later jumped back in to noted that she appreciates the new businesses.

“I just realized that when I was talking, I didn’t talk about how much we love having these new businesses. … It’s very diverse and it’s a lot of fun to have people there. And I just wanted to say that because I neglected to before.”

A Menzel Avenue resident asked for bike lanes: “I think we need bike lanes and slower traffic…. I have two young teens,” one of whom “rides his bicycle down the sidewalk with lots of pedestrians. It’s not safe. And I think adding parking on that street [Boyden] is just going to make it that much more dangerous for everybody who lives in the neighborhood.”

A number of business owners and residents noted the “blind curves” of Boyden.

One Menzel Avenue resident named Lauren asked that the township to implement traffic calming flex posts like the ones recently installed at Tuscan and Boyden.

“It looks great. It’s a new thing this year. And I think, it’s wonderful for all the kids crossing up by Seth Boyden School. And if something like that could happen further down on Boyden where all the shops are and that sort of crazy blind curve right there, I think could be very helpful.”

A Jacoby Street resident named Kelly noted that she lives “30 paces from Porta Rossa, and 70 paces from the cheese shop, probably 100 paces from Corner Slice. And I love them.”

“What I don’t love,” said Kelly, “is the two-way traffic on my street that makes it dangerous for me to pull out. What I don’t love is people turning around in my driveway and nearly hitting the kids in it. I think that the speed humps are absolutely necessary for public safety. I think that a one-way street, and I don’t care which way, … It needs to come because the streets aren’t wide enough for two cars to pass one another without almost hitting a parked car.”

What’s Next?

Two days before the HNA meeting, the Maplewood Township Committee held a somewhat tense discussion on the “Maplewood East/ Lightning Brook/East Hilton Development” — with the TC ultimately agreeing to allow the Code Committee to work on an updated plan for the area.

“Obviously it’s no news to anyone that we’ve been seeing expansion of small business development and even some housing density over by Newark Way, Boyden Avenue, and the surrounding area,” said Township Committee member and Code Committee Chair Dean Dafis. “And certainly there’s been a lot of discussion at the Planning Board and the Zoning Board of Adjustment about what uses in that area that are currently prohibited and were not contemplated previously, should be allowed.”

“What I will seek support for is some sort of understanding that we as the Township Committee, along with the Planning Board, need to plan ahead. In some ways, we’re already being responsive to what is already occurring,” said Dafis. “But what I’m looking for is support for a collaborative plan involving all relevant stakeholders, our planning officials, the organization that helped us fashion our 2022/2023 master plan, the residents themselves, the business and property owners in this area, to come together and explore what combination of employment, small business, housing, arts, production, mobility, and neighborhood protections would best serve this part of Maplewood over the next 20 years.”

Dafis noted that there were two districts under consideration: “One is the neighborhood business zone along Boyden Avenue, and the other one is the commercial industrial zone along Newark Way. There are two different districts.”

Watch the discussion beginning at 1:07:05 in the video:

“The 2022/2023 master plan, as I mentioned, did not contemplate the evolution that we are now experiencing,” said Dafis, adding, “The Zoning Board has asked the township to address the policy question legislatively rather than continuing to require applicants to seek use variances ad hoc application by application.”

TC member Nancy Adams said she supported the idea.

“We have a consulting engineer who’s currently looking at the traffic patterns and the parking on several streets over in that area and will be hopefully coming back with a recommendation,” said Adams. “But while not necessarily in favor of changing the zoning, I think since this keeps coming up and we typically take from the zoning board, guidance, if you will, or consider their requests for the governing body to look into issues that they keep getting variance requests for. And so I’m willing to take steps to have a planning board subcommittee or whatever it is, to … get public input. ”

Mayor Vic De Luca appeared to be the lone holdout.

“I have to tell you, I think any action at this point would be disrespectful to the residents who live there,” said De Luca, noting that the HNA forum was scheduled in two days.

“I think that we have heard people come in and they’ve told us that we have to address some things, and I think that’s what we’re trying to do,” said De Luca. “And I think that if we were to go out there and say that we are planning any kind of a study to make changes on Newark Way, … I think it would be disrespectful to the frustration that people feel there. And they’re looking at us to solve that.”

De Luca voiced displeasure with a 9-page memo that Dafis had created and presented at the October Code Committee meeting which proffered several potential solutions for zoning on Newark Way (see the memo attached below).

“Let’s be totally honest about the paper,” said De Luca. “It talks about three options and then it comes to a conclusion. … So I don’t think it’s being set up as an independent process.”

“I think we should spend the next two months solving the problems that have been brought to us,” said De Luca. “And once we solve those problems, we can engage in a broader discussion. We’re gonna lose credibility if we go out there and say, ‘We’re trying to solve new problems, but we’re gonna open up more uses on Newark Way.’ We’re going to bring more people without solving the underlying problem of parking and traffic.”

Dafis pushed back.

“Can I respond … because I do think that for the public record, in fairness, there’s a couple of things that got a little gray there,” said Dafis. “The proposed timeline that I put is 21 months. So this is not happening today or tomorrow. We’re not proposing going out to the community and saying, ‘We’re putting in new uses today or anytime soon.’ The proposed timeline is 21 months, and that timeline is very flexible. Also, to the point that this is subjective and driven by someone in particular or any group in particular is not fair because again, in my document, I mentioned the diverse stakeholders that would be involved here, and those are the typical stakeholders involved in any sort of study of this nature. And then thirdly, and the word community and the residents comes up all the time because the residents are part of this discussion.”

“Mobility and traffic, pedestrian safety are always part of these discussions and this kind of policy making,” said Dafis. “So in this instance, it shouldn’t be mutually exclusive. In the meantime, new variance applications will be approved before we solve the parking problem, increasing density and increasing congestion in the area.”

He added, “I do think we can do both things in parallel and be more holistic about it.”

Deputy Mayor Malia Herman sought to broker the peace.

“I think you both are saying the same thing,” said Herman. “What struck me at, reading through the memo that Mr. Dafis prepared, was that it talks about including the community and the residents in this process. It lays out a very long process.”

Herman said, “The changes are going to happen no matter what. And the Zoning Board is continuing to get applications. They’re continuing to consider them.”

She added, “I think that we are absolutely doing the right thing by having the study done and moving forward on dealing with these specific concerns that need to be dealt with. … It’s time to start working together with the community, with the stakeholders, and deciding as a community, as a governing body, moving it forward.”

Later Herman noted, “I just wanted to point out real quickly that it’s not a resident against businesses type of situation. Many of the residents, and even the ones who came to the Planning Board, said that they love the businesses that are there. They enjoy going and getting fresh pasta and going to these businesses. They were pointing out the issues that they’re having with the traffic and the parking, but they absolutely are welcoming” the businesses.

TC Member Jane Collins-Colding also struck a conciliatory tone.

“What the Mayor was talking about, we need to address the immediate need for the things that the residents are upset about. Long-term, between the time that Dean talked about, I think it’s important that we lay out a plan because … it’s going to continue to happen and we’re going to have more problems. I think the same thing we did with DeHart, talking to the residents, just bringing them in and having those conversations to ask them what they want….”

“We can start from there. And asking the businesses as well, because there has to be a partnership and there has to be a come to Jesus moment. They have to work together,” said Collins-Colding. “The businesses are there, the residents are there. … We have to listen to both parties and then decide what’s going to happen.”

Later De Luca dug in.

“This paper already makes a conclusion,” said De Luca, referencing Dafis’s memo again. “I think that’s the problem. The problem is that on one hand, we’re arguing you have an independent conversation and bring everybody together, but we’re telling them that the strongest starting point is to do an overlay zone or to do a transition on northwest. That’s what we’re saying. I’m just saying we’re going to lose credibility with the community.”

“So we don’t do that,” said Dafis. “It’s just a suggestion, right?”

“Let me finish,” said De Luca.

“It’s already out there,” said De Luca. “This was a letter from five members of the Zoning Board that asked us to take a look at this. This was not a vote of the Zoning Board. We get an annual report from the Zoning Board, and it tells us all the variances they gave us, have given. And we take a look at that to see if there needs to be changes. But the very nature of a variance, a use variance, is you have to show that the positives outweigh the negatives. And that’s how it’s set up. So if there are good ideas, like the good ideas that have occurred on Newark Way, then they’re going to continue to get variances. But we have to take a look at everything else there. And if we want to engage in a long process, we better not go out there saying that we already know what we want to accomplish.”

“It’s a suggested memo,” said Dafis. “It is not a Planning Board document. It is not a resolution by the Township Committee. It’s a work product from a subcommittee. And I also want to read from the municipal land use law the following: ‘Variances are a lawful safety valve, but use variances are intended for particular cases involving special reasons and require five affirmative Zoning Board votes. They are not a sound substitute for legislative planning across an entire district.'”

“We don’t need to belabor the point,” said Dafis. “So the next step is what? To get some recommendations on how to move forward?”

The TC then agreed to send the issue back to the Code Committee to study.

Download (PDF, 165KB)

More Stories

CLOSE
CLOSE