Architect to Present Plans to Save Historic Squier House to South Orange Trustees Feb. 22

by Mary Barr Mann
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

On February 22, a local architect will update the South Orange Board of Trustees on plans and progress made to save the historic Squier House at 167 N. Ridgewood Road. Meanwhile, the South Orange Historical & Preservation Society will be introducing a GoFundMe page to raise funds to cover costs for researching and developing the plans (link to come).

As previously reported, a win-win for preservationists and the property owner has been proposed: While the property owner, Ampere Development, was granted a lot line adjustment on Feb. 1 by the South Orange Planning Board that could pave the way for demolition of the circa-1774 Squier House, the developer has indicated an openness saving the house by applying to create three lots. This would allow for the construction of two new homes on two lots and the preservation of the historic section of the Squire House on a third lot.

South Orange-based architect Bill MacIntosh reports, “The relationship with the developers Isaac and Henry Lefkowitz (Ampere Development) continues to be very positive and collaborative. It was actually Isaac who recommended reconsidering 2 lots to 3 lots so the old house could be sold on its own, not me. I had been trying to work with his two lots, with the old house as an accessory dwelling.”

“For the house to be saved, the deal has to make financial sense for developer,” adds MacIntosh. “And the complexity of this kind of renovation is not their typical project. So we are very grateful they are making this extra effort to give us a little time to see if/how this historic farmhouse, hidden behind hedges and little known to most until now, can be saved!”

Neighbor Anne Wessel explained the historic significance of the building in a release this weekend: “Built in 1774 by Henry Squier, the farmhouse is significant not only for its architecture, but its history. Henry, a revolutionary war officer, was instrumental in starting the ‘Academy at Orange Dale’, now the Orange Public School System. His son, Nathan, served as a High Sheriff, a judge of the Inferior Court, a Free Holder, and a Trustee and President of the Board of the South Orange Columbian School. Nathan Squier owned cider mills and distilleries, an interest in a sawmill, and built and operated the South Orange Hotel. Circa 1795, Nathan Squier is credited with naming the Village of South Orange. William Redmond bought the land inclusive of the Squire house in 1850 and rented it to Mr. Flood, who used the hill as his cow pasture for his home delivery milk service.  The Squire House remained in the Redmond family until current owners purchased in 1988.”

MacIntosh provided a preview of his February 22 BOT presentation via email:

Developments in last couple weeks:

  • MacIntosh has collaborated with Ampere Development and their civil engineer to get a site plan for three lots that retains the original house and works functionally and aesthetically for the two new houses to either side.
  • But this subdivision / site plan will require variances. 8 total.
  • The developer has expedited revising the subdivision application for three lots and resubmitted to South Orange this past week. The earlier two-lot subdivision was approved that would have demolished the old house.
  • MacIntosh presented with the developer, Isaac Lefkowtiz, to the South Orange Historic Preservation Commission last Thursday night. MacIntosh made the case why the variances should be approved, based on the benefit to the community for preserving one of only three remaining 1700s houses in South Orange, and on historic precedent for multiple structures on this site. 
  • The SOHPC is issuing a letter endorsing the variances to the Planning Board.
  • In addition to the site planning, MacIntosh’s recent work has also included preliminary design studies for adapting the old part of the house to be an attractive, marketable 4-bedroom house. Initial findings are promising.
  • Actual feasibility will depend on further work to test structural integrity, develop a schematic design, have this priced and compare to the likely sale price. This work is being expedited given the delays to the developer.
  • MacIntosh presented Friday 2/19 at 10:00 a.m. with Village President Sheena Collum, two trustees, the developer, members of SOHPC and SOHPS, A representative of the Village’s professional planner, and neighborhood stakeholders on a WebEx to update them. Collum then asked MacIntosh to present to the Trustees. 
After the zoning approval, the next hurdle to saving the house is proving financial feasibility:
  • A first step here is a comprehensive assessment of the existing structure. A prominent preservation structural engineer has already done a pro bono field visit and issued a memo noting that from what can be seen, it appears in better than expected condition for a 247-year old structure and with some repairs the structure can be renovated.
  • The cost to retain them to do the assessment, a contractor to do probes for this assessment and a house inspector are the subject of a GoFundMe initiative about to be launched Monday by the South Orange Historical and Preservation Society. These funds are not going to the developer, but rather to assess the preservation aspects of determining if the condition of the existing structure and systems.
  • MacIntosh is continuing to work pro bono through completion of a schematic design. This entailed taking lots of dimensions last weekend to get reliable base drawings. 
  • A contractor has agreed to do a pro bono preliminary cost estimate for budget purposes.
  • After schematic design, the developer will need to hire an architect and engineers to do construction drawings.  TBD who these parties will be.

Tune into the South Orange Board of Trustee meeting on Monday, February 22, starting at 7 p.m.:

Related Articles